"Love follows knowledge."
"Beauty above all beauty!"
– St. Catherine of Siena

Wednesday, February 17, 2021

Music Wednesday: Miserere Mei Deus

Yes, I know.  It’s supposed to be Music Tuesday, but today is Ash Wednesday, the beginning of Lent, and I wanted to commemorate it with a perfect music piece for the day.  It’s Gregorio Allegri’s Miserere mei, Deus, a polyphonic choral piece composed around 1638.  Wikipedia explains it better than I can.

 

 Miserere (full title: Miserere mei, Deus, Latin for "Have mercy on me, O God") is a setting of Psalm 51 by Italian composer Gregorio Allegri. It was composed during the reign of Pope Urban VIII, probably during the 1630s, for the exclusive use of the Sistine Chapel during the Tenebrae services of Holy Week, and its mystique was increased by unwritten performance traditions and ornamentation. It is written for two choirs, of five and four voices respectively, singing alternately and joining to sing the ending in 9-part polyphony.

You can read the history of the piece in that Wikipedia entry.  It’s interesting.

So this is the penitential 51st psalm set to song, and one that should be prayed repeatedly during Lent.  This rendition, conducted and arranged by Edward Higginbottom is just stunningly beautiful. 

 


The lyrics are listed but I’ll present them here.  First in Latin.

 

Miserere mei, Deus: secundum magnam misericordiam tuam.

Et secundum multitudinem miserationum tuarum, dele iniquitatem meam.

Amplius lava me ab iniquitate mea: et a peccato meo munda me.

Quoniam iniquitatem meam ego cognosco: et peccatum meum contra me est semper.

Tibi soli peccavi, et malum coram te feci: ut justificeris in sermonibus tuis, et vincas cum judicaris.

Ecce enim in iniquitatibus conceptus sum: et in peccatis concepit me mater mea.

Ecce enim veritatem dilexisti: incerta et occulta sapientiae tuae manifestasti mihi.

Asperges me hysopo, et mundabor: lavabis me, et super nivem dealbabor.

Auditui meo dabis gaudium et laetitiam: et exsultabunt ossa humiliata.

Averte faciem tuam a peccatis meis: et omnes iniquitates meas dele.

Cor mundum crea in me, Deus: et spiritum rectum innova in visceribus meis.

Ne proiicias me a facie tua: et spiritum sanctum tuum ne auferas a me.

Redde mihi laetitiam salutaris tui: et spiritu principali confirma me.

Docebo iniquos vias tuas: et impii ad te convertentur.

Libera me de sanguinibus, Deus, Deus salutis meae: et exsultabit lingua mea justitiam tuam.

Domine, labia mea aperies: et os meum annuntiabit laudem tuam.

Quoniam si voluisses sacrificium, dedissem utique: holocaustis non delectaberis.

Sacrificium Deo spiritus contribulatus: cor contritum, et humiliatum, Deus, non despicies.

Benigne fac, Domine, in bona voluntate tua Sion: ut aedificentur muri Ierusalem.

Tunc acceptabis sacrificium justitiae, oblationes, et holocausta: tunc imponent super altare tuum vitulos.

 

English translation (Douay Rheims)

 

Have mercy on me, O God, according to thy great mercy.

And according to the multitude of thy tender mercies blot out my iniquity.

Wash me yet more from my iniquity, and cleanse me from my sin.

For I know my iniquity, and my sin is always before me.

To thee only have I sinned, and have done evil before thee: that thou mayst be justified in thy words and mayst overcome when thou art judged.

For behold I was conceived in iniquities; and in sins did my mother conceive me.

For behold thou hast loved truth: the uncertain and hidden things of thy wisdom thou hast made manifest to me.

Thou shalt sprinkle me with hyssop, and I shall be cleansed: thou shalt wash me, and I shall be made whiter than snow.

To my hearing thou shalt give joy and gladness: and the bones that have been humbled shall rejoice.

Turn away thy face from my sins, and blot out all my iniquities.

Create a clean heart in me, O God: and renew a right spirit within my bowels.

Cast me not away from thy face; and take not thy holy spirit from me.

Restore unto me the joy of thy salvation, and strengthen me with a perfect spirit.

I will teach the unjust thy ways: and the wicked shall be converted to thee.

Deliver me from blood, O God, thou God of my salvation: and my tongue shall extol thy justice.

O Lord, thou wilt open my lips: and my mouth shall declare thy praise.

For if thou hadst desired sacrifice, I would indeed have given it: with burnt offerings thou wilt not be delighted.

A sacrifice to God is an afflicted spirit: a contrite and humbled heart, O God, thou wilt not despise.

Deal favourably, O Lord, in thy good will with Sion; that the walls of Jerusalem may be built up.

Then shalt thou accept the sacrifice of justice, oblations and whole burnt offerings: then shall they lay calves upon thy altar.

 

Perhaps you can visit this choral several times during Lent.  The lyrics are part of the video.  You can pray it as you listen.

Wednesday, February 10, 2021

My 2021 Plans

It’s well into 2021 and it’s about time I posted on my annual plans.  Since I am locked into my Catholic Thought Book Club at Goodreads, I’m limited in what I can choose to read.  We nominate and vote on books, so I can’t predict what will be selected.  On a fair amount of selections, I have to flow with the spirit.


Here’s what I do know.  We are currently reading Acts of the Apostles from the New Testament, and at some point later this year we will pick up on the second part of St. Augustine’s City of God.  We are currently in the process of selecting our next read, and I’m hoping that Dark Night of the Soul (both the poem and his commentary) by St. John of the Cross gets selected.  A number of people have expressed interest in reading it too, so I am hopeful enough to put it in my plans here. 

I am also currently reading Rumer Godden’s In This House of Brede, a novel about a middle-aged, career woman who quits her job and joins a Benedictine monastery.  Godden was a Catholic convert.  This is one of her best known novels.

Now that I am finished with Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables, I can continue to read more novels from the French.  I have long wanted to read Stendhal’s The Red and the Black.  And so I will begin at some point this year.

As to non-fiction, I really want to read Conservatism: An Introduction to the Great Tradition by the recently deceased Roger Scruton.  I would also love to read the confessional autobiography and conversion story, From Fire By Water: My Journey to the Catholic Faith by Sohrab Ahmari.  And also my book short reading list is the recently republished How to Read a Novel by Caroline Gordon.  Another non-fiction book that caught my eye was Skunk Works: A Personal Memoir of My Years of Lockheed by Ben R. Rich.  It’s another personal memoir which mostly details his project of the development of the stealth fighter.  I am still an engineer with engineering interests. 

The Biblical texts are nicely laid out for me.  I need to wrap up the Old Testament with the late prophets: Hosea, Joel, Amos, Obadiah, Jonah, Micah, Nahum, Habakkuk, Zephaniah, Haggai, Zechariah, and Malachi.  They will be read both in KJV and RSV translation.  With that I will have completed the entire Bible.  Along with Acts as I mentioned above, I will be reading Revelation again, and this time along with Peter S. Williamson’s Revelation: Catholic Commentary on Sacred Scripture.  I read the Biblical text last year and meant to read Williamson’s commentary but I didn’t get the chance. 



There are still the unfinished reads from last year.  Dominican Life: A Commentary on the Rule of St. Augustine, by Walter Wagner, O.P., Catholicism: A Journey to the Heart of the Faith, by Robert Barron, Prince Caspian, from the Chronicles of Narnia series by C. S. Lewis.  I have one more chapter to go with Prince Caspian and then I’ll push onto the next in the series, The Voyage of the Dawn Treader. 

Of course I’ll read as many short stories as I can, and try to reach that goal of twenty-four short stories for the year.  And I’ll continue to read the monthly devotional, Magnificat. 

And let’s see what Providence also throws in my way to read. 




Monday, February 8, 2021

Catherine of Siena by Sigrid Undset, 2nd Read, Post #6

This is the sixth and final post on the second read of Sigrid Undset’s Catherine of Siena. 

You can find Post #1 here.  

Post #2 here.  

Post #3 here. 

Post #4 here.  

Post #5 here. 

 

Chapter 24

Catherine continuous her furious letter writing, this time to everyone and for all occasions, some to her personal friends and some for the cause of Pope Urban VI.  In one letter to Raimondo she chastises him for being afraid of being killed on the road of a mission he backed out, and then in another letter she forgives him for his weakness.  Her mother Lapa also joins Catherine in Rome.

Chapter 25

Undset narrates how the schism caused deep factions in Europe, where leaders and religious took sides.  Eventually the schism turned violent as the King of France sent a military expedition to Italy, attacking some of the Italian cities and finally Rome.  But the Pope’s army with its paid mercenaries overturned the French force, many thanking Catherine for the victory.  Her letter writing continued strongly, even writing to Queen Joanna again, and this time it may have appeared Joanna changed her side to Urban, though she probably did it for Machiavellian reasons rather than what was right.

Chapter 26

As the year turned 1380, Catherine began to weaken as the Romans began to rebel against Pope Urban.  By now she had become emaciated.  Devils began to attack her both physically and spiritually.  At times she could not walk; other times she struggled to walk to Mass and the Vatican.  Sensing her life was waning, she wrote a letter to the Holy Father advising him how to comport himself in this struggle of the schism.  She wrote a last letter to Raimondo telling him of her final spiritual struggles, and to take charge of her writings, and finally offering her life for the Church and glory of God.

Chapter 27

By the middle of Lent in 1380, Catherine was unable to leave her bed.  By the Holy week her old confessor, Fra Bartolommeo Dominici, came to Rome and spent time with her.  She made her confession and he celebrated Mass in her room.  By April, Catherine had made her spiritual last will and testament, gathered all her sons and daughters, including her mother, and individually blessed them and gave them each final advice.  She made a final open confession to them all, received absolution again, and on April 29th passed away while in prayer.

Chapter 28

At the hour of Catherine’s death, Raimondo recalls how he, leagues away in Genoa and not knowing she had passed, hearing her voice assuring his protection from heaven.  Undset also delineates how a Roman woman, Semia on the day of Catherine’s death had a dream of Catherine being led into heaven by angels, and how Semia found out about Catherine’s body lying in protection at the basilica of Santa Maria sopra Minerva and paid her respects.  Catherine was initially buried at the Basilica.

Chapter 29

Undset narrates how Catherine’s body was initially buried at the churchyard at Santa Maria sopra Minerva, then brought into the church itself where her head was cutoff and sent to Siena in a reliquary with her body entombed in the church and ultimately moved under the high altar.  Undset briefly describes the fates of her closest sons and daughters.  We learn of Catherine’s beatification and then canonization in 1461 by Pope Pius II. 

###

My Reply to Gerri:

Gerri wrote: "The fasting and staying up all night? Checkmark for a manic state. The sense of being tormented by demons/the devil - which Catherine regularly said she suffered? Checkmark for the 13th century, when bipolar disorder was unknown and a suffering person was believed to be possessed by the devil. And Catherine's recurring illnesses that sent her to her bed - checkmark for the depressive side of the illness.."

Very interesting Gerri. I could see some sort of compulsive disorder. Actually it's likely, but she was never really depressed to be bi-polar. If you remember she was always a happy upbeat person. But I do see some sort of high compulsive inner drive that just won't stop. The exhaustion was because she just pushed her self beyond her breaking point. Plus, she didn't eat. I would imagine there was no fuel in the tank.

 

My Reply to Gerri:

Gerri wrote: "Three more things. You can tell I've become a Caterinati!"

Welcome to the club! Now you see how this book really alterted me. Because of having read this book and falling in love with Catherine I ultimately became a Lay Dominican, And if you're interested, my chosen religious name is Br. John Catherine of Siena.

###

There is an interesting passage in chapter 26 of St. Catherine and the ship that is the church.

 

In the entrance to the old basilica of St. Petyer’s, there was a mosaic of Giotto’s called “Navicella”—St. Peter’s ship.  Catherine must have seen it hundreds of times, sometimes with deep thoughts, sometimes without noticing it.  But when she received the vision which assured her that her heavenly Bridegroom had accepted her prayer to sacrifice her life, the impression of this mosaic may have helped to decide the pictorial form of her vision.

 

Sexagesima Sunday fell on January 29.  Catherine was on her knees in St. Peter’s, where she had remained motionless for hours.  But suddenly at vespers her friends saw that she collapsed, as though an overwhelming burden had been laid on her shoulders and crushed her body with its weight.  When they tried to help her to her feet she was so weak that she could not stand.  Supported by two of her sons she was more carried than led home.  When they lifted her onto her bed it looked as though she were dying. 

 

Tommaso Caffarini’s description is repeated by William Flete:  As Catherine knelt at the tomb of St. Peter that Sunday at vespers, while the winter evening began to creep in over the city, she felt how Jesus Christ laid the whole weight of His Church, la Navicella, on the thin shoulders of His faithful bride.

 

And the crushing pain was sweet too—indescribably sweet.  It meant that He had accepted the sacrifice she had offered Him in love and desire.  It meant too that He would soon come and lead her from “this dark world” to the land of her desire and eternal union with Him.  (304-5)

 

I’m struck with how many contemporaneous writings about her took place and have survived.  Raimondo, Fra Dominici, Cafferini come to mind.  It helps that she was associated with Dominicans since they were the most educated order.  I also want to point out that image of Giotto’s “Navicella.”  It is an exquisite work of art.  You can read about it here and if you click the picture you will get it in full screen and fully appreciate it.  


More importantly, Catherine takes the image and interprets it as her burden.  The crushing weight of the ship—which stands for the church herself—becomes the means of her martyrdom.  Undset goes on to describe Catherine’ last letter to Pope Urban, written just after this incident, even quoting extensively from it.  I went and looked up that actual letter and found that Undset did not quote this particular sentence: “Comfort you, and do not fear on account of any bad reply which this rebel against your Holiness may have made or may make, for God will care for this and for everything else, as Ruler and Helper of the ship of Holy Church, and of your Holiness.”  [Saint of Siena Catherine. Letters of Catherine Benincasa (Kindle Locations 3921-3923).]  Notice she calls him “Ruler and Helper of the ship of Holy Church.”  The ship is clearly on her mind.  I also want to point out that sometimes you may see an image or icon of St. Catherine holding a ship.  This is what the image is referring to, Catherine holding up the bark of Peter.  Here is an example.  


###

Some of Catherine’s last words are interesting.  For instance, toward the end when her children are gathered round her bed in sorrow, she says:

 

“And I promise you that I shall be with you always, and be of much more use to you on the other side than I ever could be here on earth, for then I shall have left the darkness behind me and move in the eternal light.”  (p. 317)

The first part of that—“I shall be with you always”—is a quote right out of the Gospel of Matthew, the very last lines in fact.  Jesus’ parting words are “And behold, I am with you always, until the end of the age” (Mat 28:20).  So there she is quoting Jesus.

The next part is also a famous quote, that is, famous to the Order of Preachers.  Catherine says “[I will] be of much more use to you on the other side than I ever could be here on earth.”  Those words are very similar to that of St. Dominic himself, the founder of the order.  On his death bed, he too had his close friars beside him in morning.  The situation is exactly parallel to that of Catherine in this scene.  St. Dominic’s words are, “Do not weep, my children; I shall be more useful to you where I am now going, than I have ever been in this life” (p. 225 from The Life of Saint Dominic, Augusta Theodosia Drane, 1988 by TAN Books, Charlotte, North Carolina, first published in 1857, London).  Every Dominican knows those words of St. Dominic.  It must have been on Catherine’s mind.

And the last part, “for then I shall have left the darkness behind me and move in the eternal light,” that movement from darkness to light is all over the Bible, but Catherine’s words seem to echo Jesus as He quotes Isaiah, “Land of Zebulun and land of Naphtali, the way to the sea, beyond the Jordan, Galilee of the Gentiles, the people who sit in darkness have seen a great light, on those dwelling in a land overshadowed by death light has arisen” (Mat 4:15-6).  When you live in the words of God, you repeat the words of God, consciously or unconsciously. 

Let’s closely look at her moment of death as Undset depicts it.

 

Catherine continued to pray till the last moment, for the Church, forPope Urban, for her children.  She prayed with such intense love that her disciples thought that not only their hearts, but the very stones must break.  “Beloved, You call me, I come.  Not through any service of mine, but through Your mercy and the power of Your blood…”  She made the sign of the cross and cried, “Blood, blood…”  Then she bowed her head.  “Father, into Your hands I commit my spirit.”  And as she said it, she gave up the spirit.  Her face had become as beautiful as an angel’s, radiant with tenderness and happiness. 

 

It was about the hour of terce on April 29, 1380. (320)

Terce, the Third Hour, is about 9 AM.  Her last words of “Father, into Your hands I commit my spirit” is a little too neat.  I personally don’t believe it.  I’ve been reading I Am Going: Reflections on the Last Words of Saints by Mary Katherine Glavich, SND, and she lists “Blood, blood…” as Catherine’s last words.  Her lifelong obsession with Christ’s blood makes that perfectly reasonable and fitting to be her last words.  Those are the last words I consider she said.


###

I was moved by Undset’s final words on Catherine.

 

It is certain that Catherine voluntarily—and few women have ever had such an inflexible will—chose to suffer ceaselessly for all she believed in, loved and desired: unity with God, the glory and honor of His name, His kingdom on earth, the eternal happiness of all mankind, and the re-birth of Christ’s Church to the beauty which it possesses when the radiance of its soul shines freely through its outward form—that form which was then stained and spoilt by its own degenerative servants and rebellious children.  As Catherine expressed it: the strength and beauty of its mystical body can never diminish, for it is God; but the jewels with which its mystical body are adorned are the good accomplished by its sincere and faithful children. 

Wow, what beautifully constructed sentences.  And the imagery is wonderful too: the good works we do in our love of God are jewels that adorn His mystical body.  Is the imagery Undset’s or is she paraphrasing it from Catherine?  It sounds like one of those visual images St. Catherine would come up with.

###

My Goodreads Review:

This is probably the best biography of a saint I have ever read, and no wonder.  It’s written by Sigrid Undset, Nobel Prize winning author.  Undset was a convert to Catholicism, and even became a Lay Dominican.  Many of Undset’s novels are set in the Middle Ages, so it’s no surprise then she would write a biography of the most important Lay Dominican to have ever lived and one of the most influential women of the fourteenth century, St. Catherine of Siena.  What is amazing about this biography is that though it has elements of a hagiography, it is detailed and reads like a work of realism.  I’m even more impressed on my second read than after the first.

Why is the life of St. Catherine so engaging?  St. Catherine of Siena incorporates into her being every element of sainthood possible.  She lived a life of uncompromising holiness.  You may be surprised to learn she was not a consecrated religious, but a Third Order Dominican.  Prayer was the foundation of her life, which then led to an active ministry of taking care of the sick and the poor.  She was a mystic who had who supernatural experiences on an almost daily basis but was involved in the issues and politics of her day.  Though uneducated, she learned Catholic theology so well she was correcting theologians, and she went on to write—at some point she learned to read and write either mystically or through perseverance—one of the great Catholic theological classics, her Dialogue.  I marvel at her writings—mostly her letters—for her intense prose and wonderful imagery.  She was a natural poet.  She was a little woman from a non-aristocratic family who became so influential she was offering advice to kings and queens, and her greatest accomplishment was in persuading Pope Gregory XI to return the papacy to Rome after almost a century in Avignon.  Her greatest disappointment was in not being able to resolve the Papal Schism of 1378, and here too she offered her life up in ascetic martyrdom in the hopes of a resolution.  Because of her brilliance in articulating the faith, in 1970, along with St. Teresa of Avila, she was recognized as a Doctor of the Church, the first women.  And though her asceticism was severe, she was never dour.  On the contrary she one of the most affable and gregarious women of her time.  She attracted a large following known as the Caterinati.  Read this bio and perhaps you will be a Caterinati too!



Sunday, February 7, 2021

Sunday Meditation: To a Deserted Place to Pray

What a busy day Jesus has in the first chapter of Mark.  But then He needed some solitude that next morning.

 

“Rising very early before dawn, he left

and went off to a deserted place, where he prayed..”

       -Mark 1:35

Where is your deserted place to pray?




Friday, February 5, 2021

Faith Filled Friday: My St. Catherine of Siena Statue

I wonder if this could count as a miracle.  It’s certainly wondrous and remarkable.  Every so often I enjoy surfing through the St. Dominic Store.  To quote their website it’s a “religious goods online store associated with the Lay Provincial Council of the Lay Fraternities of St. Dominic of the Holy Name of Jesus (Western) Province of the Order of Preachers (Dominicans); and, St. Dominic's Store is affiliated with the Third Order of St. Dominic.”    Simply put it’s a gift shop of the Lay Dominicans of the western province of the United States.  A little over a week ago I came across a twelve inch high statue of St. Catherine of Siena.  My heart leaped, and it was only $37 dollars! 

It was beautiful, made in Italy of paste marble (whatever that is) and hand painted.  Everyone here knows my love for everything Santa Catarina.  I’ve always wanted such a statue and never found one to my liking.  This looked perfect.  Of course I ordered it, along with a couple of small items, just to make the order worth it.  But the statue was the key.

In the week that it took to get to me, I got antsy and wanted to see the statue again.  I returned to the website.  I couldn’t find it.  I went through every category, “Statues,” “St. Catherine,” “Dominican Items,” nothing, not there.  Huh?  Where did it go?  Did I buy the last one?  If so it would say sold out or something like that.  If anyone can find it there, please send me the link.

So this got me motivated to look for this statue elsewhere.  Did it really exist?  I checked Amazon.  No not there.  I did a search under religious statues, and I could not find it.  Finally I did find the very statue at a website for the gift shop at the Basilica Caterina in Siena, Italy.  It was the very one: “STATUE OF SAINT CATHERINE. CROWN OF THORNS SIZE 41”  They sold it for 58 Euros.  I quickly looked up the conversion of Euros to dollars, and it translates to about $70.  So I got it for half the price and didn’t need to pay shipping costs from Italy.  Wow!

This is all very strange and certainly divinely sent.  Thank you God.  Thank you St. Catherine.

So once it arrived I took some pictures to show you.  First the entire length.

 


Next, mid body up. 

 


The book she is holding indicates she is a Doctor of the Church and the lilies that she was a life-long virgin.

 


The base says “Santa Caterina.”  Of course you realize that’s Italian for “St. Catherine.” 

From the back.

 


The halo has a crown of thorns around it.  Finally some close ups of her face.



 


Isn’t she beautiful?  What a wonderful sacramental this will make.  I still can’t find it on the St. Dominic Store website.  This was heaven sent.

Wednesday, February 3, 2021

Photo Essay: SNOVID ‘21

I loved the front page headline from today’s (2/2/21) New York Post: Stuck at home, locked down—it’s not COVID-19, it’s SNOVID’21.

I guess you may have heard we had a Nor’easter.  New York City was supposed to get 18 to 24 inches.  Parts of the city may have gotten that.  North of New York City I heard they got anywhere from 30 to 36 inches.  Yikes!  Three feet.  Here on Staten Island we may have gotten 18 inches but to my eye it looks a little short of that.  We’re on the southern end of the city.  The more north you were, the more snow you got.  I just love that NY Post headline.  They have the best headlines.

Some pictures.  From my front slider.




From my back deck. 




Also from my back deck looking out into the convent with the statue of the Blessed Mother and Child. 




Did I ever mention behind my house is a convent?  Unfortunately they have sold the property and will be moving out, but I have been blessed all these years.

Finally my car on the street if you can make it out. 




The car is still buried.  My back is hurting.  I need a day of rest. 

Tuesday, February 2, 2021

Catherine of Siena by Sigrid Undset, 2nd Read, Post #5

This is the fifth post on the second read of Sigrid Unset’s Catherine of Siena. 

You can find Post #1 here.  

Post #2 here. 

Post #3 here. 

Post #4 here.   


Summaries for chapters 19 through 23 were written by Gerri Bauer for our Goodreads, Catholic Thought book club.  (I didn’t have the time to keep up and Gerri did me a favor.  Thank you Gerri.)

Chapter 19

Catherine is called mediate a feud between two branches of the Salimbeni family. While at their fortress, a possessed women is brought to Catherine for healing - causing Catherine to cry out because she suffers so much from attacks by demons. But she is the victor in the struggle for the woman. Also, while at the fortress, Catherine discovers she can write. She says this occurred while she was in ecstasy. She also survives an attack by a monk who was in despair and tries to kill her.

Chapter 20

Catherine heads to Florence as the Pope's ambassador, without any priests accompanying her because the town is under an interdict. Catherine's friends and enemies agree that she is well versed in everything concerning the Church, is very learned, and has a brilliant intuitive understanding of things. A peace conference starts at the beginning of 1378 but Pope Gregory XI dies on March 27 before peace is secured. A fierce civil war breaks out in Florence. Catherine faces down a mob that comes to murder her in Soderini's garden. She offers her life but begs them to spare her companions. The mob leaves but the war continues. At one point, Catherine flees to nearby woods but soon returns to town. While in Florence, she writes her first letter to Pope Urban VI, urging mercy as well as reform of the Church. She also again calls for a crusade after peace is established in Florence. Peace finally comes in July and Catherine returns to Siena.

Chapter 21

When Pope Gregory XI died, Rome was in chaos. Romans formed mobs and stormed the Vatican, screaming that a Roman must be elected or the cardinals would be murdered. Terrified cardinals rushed through the election and chose the Archbishop of Bari, Bartolommeo Prignano, who became Urban VI. As soon as the crowds were told there was a new Pope, the mob broke down the doors and forced their way in, again repeating the threat. (A Roman noble, Cardinal Tebaldeschi, was presented to the mob as the new Pope.) The cardinals in Avignon, supported by Provencal colleagues, refused to accept any declarations sent out in Urban's name. On Sept. 20, a schismatic Pope was elected. Catherine, meanwhile, is back in Siena and dictates so many letters she keeps three secretaries busy. She writes numerous letters supporting Urban as the lawful Pope. Undset says she had foreseen the schism.

Chapter 22

Catherine removes herself to a solitary dwelling outside the gates of Siena and dictates the book that becomes known as the "Dialogue." She asks her secretaries to listen when she is in ecstasy and write down all she says. Catherine calls the manuscript "the book" or "my book." Undset says a belief in God's mercy is the undercurrent of the conversations between the Eternal Father and His dear daughter, a much loved child. In the Dialogue, the Lord repeats for Catherine all he has taught her. The contents are revealed to Catherine during a series of visions that take place over four or five days. This Chapter goes into depth about the Dialogue.

Channel 23

Catherine starts on a journey to Rome and arrives Nov. 28 to find the town under arms. The Pope can't move into the Vatican and is staying at Santa Maria in Trastevere. He asks Catherine to make a speech to the cardinals about the schism. She urges them to show courage. Pope Urban also asks Catherine and another virgin named Katherine to go as his ambassadors to Queen Joanna of Naples, who supports the schismatics. Katherine refuses for personal reasons, so neither woman goes. But Catherine had already written to Joanna from Siena, with a plea for the lawful Pope. She writes again, but Joanna ignores the pleas. Catherine and her companions settle in a house near Santa Maria sopra Minerva. Christmas is approaching, and it will be the first Catherine celebrates in Rome. 


###

My Comment to Gerri:

Gerri! Thank you so much for summarizing these chapters. I am behind. Besides what seems a busier than usual week, the election and the results has had me distracted.

 

"Distracted from distraction by distraction," one of my favorite quotes from TS Eliot.

 

Now let me get to reading these chapters and I will comment. Bless you.

My Comment:

Gerri, I just finished chapter 22 which was on the Dialogue. Undset only gives us a smattering from the book. I too want to read it, but I'm told is a little chaotic. Remember it was dictated while Catherine was in ecstasy and so I'm told it can be hard to absorb. I've read that Catherine intended to edit it but she couldn't bring herself to do it because she felt it came from the mouth of God. The Dialogue is a conversation between her and God.

There is a condensed version that cuts the repetitions and makes things flow logically. Little Talks With God. Perhaps that's a better choice for the book club to start if we can get it voted in as a read. 

My Comment:

On page 285 I was struck with Undset saying that Catherine "was such a good cook." I've never seen that anywhere else. She made the candied oranges for the pope. If she cooked then she had to to taste, no? And if she tasted, she had to have had some nutrition.

 

But I'm startled to see she was a good cook. That is surprising to me.

My Comment:

On page 282 she chastises two hermits for not getting personally involved in healing the schism, one of the two being William Fleete. She says about him, "I sigh from the bottom of my heart over his stupidity, for he does not seek the glory of God and the good of his neighbor with noticeable zeal." Apparently she didn't think his being a hermit was an excuse. She being a Dominican I can see why she would have a hard time with it. She tells him later, "The glow of your faith cannot be very ardent if you risk losing it by changing your dwelling. It seems as though God cares about places, and is only to be found in solitude and no other place in the day of need."

 

Now think back when she was in her cell of self-knowledge and did not want to come out. She only came out on Christ's insistence. I think she was eighteen at the time. Now, here, she is around thirty or thirty-one. She has grown much over that time.

Gerri Replied:

She called things as she saw them. It's one reason why, after reading this book, I consider her fearless. She was disappointed when she perceived Raimondo to be shying away from potential martyrdom, and she told him so. I marvel at her boldness in expressing strong opinions and in getting away with doing so.

 

I agree with you about the Dialogue. Your suggested book is a good one to put up for a future read vote.

My Reply to Gerri:

Oh she was so courageous. And just think about her travels. A woman just didn't do that back then. 

###



I was taken a little by surprised in chapter 23 by how much Catherine was involved in solving the great schism.  We frequently hear of Catherine’s having convinced Pope Gregory XI to return the papacy back to Rome, and perhaps rightly so since that was a great achievement, but her efforts to heal the schism is also a great effort, even though she was not successful.  I didn’t realize (actually I must have forgotten since I have read this before) how much Pope Urban VI relied on her to help support the legitimacy of his papacy.  I thought she just came to Rome and prayed to end the schism, but we see a lot more than that in chapter 23, but it hardly gets mentioned in the Catholic world of today.  I guess an achievement is always more historically lasting in people’s memory than a failed effort, but this effort should be documented.  Allow me to pull some short excerpts from the chapter to highlight and in my small little way hopefully disseminate knowledge of Catherine’s great participation to end the schism.

Let me start with Catherine being received by Pope Urban VI in Rome.

 

Catherine was immediately received by the Pope, who was overwhelmed with joy at meeting her again.  He asked her to make a speech to the assembled cardinals, first and foremost about the schism, which had now become a fact.  She did so in such a way that everyone was greatly moved.  She encouraged them to show courage and determination, and brought forward many reasons for this.  She explained how God’s providence watched over each individual in such a way in these times which brought great suffering on Holy Church.  Therefore, she said finally, they should not let themselves be frightened by the schism, but persevere and work for God without fear of me.  When she finished her talk the Pope seemed extremely happy.  He summed up what she had said and added to the cardinals: “See, brothers, how guilty we must appear to God because we are without courage.  This little woman puts us to shame.  And when I call her a little woman [piccola donzella] I do not do so out of scorn, but because her sex is by nature fearful; but see how we tremble while she is strong and calm, and see how consoles us with her words.  (p. 274)

There is that courage of hers highlighted again; everyone sees it.  Can you imagine in the 14th century a woman being asked to speak in front of an assembly of cardinals, and then delivering a motivating speech, probably off the cuff?  She is amazing.

Pope Urban had plans to use her across Italy.

 

A day or two later Urban suggested that Catherine and another virgin, also called Katherine, should go as his ambassadors to Queen Joanna of Naples, who now openly supported the schismatics.  This other Katherine was the daughter of St. Birgitta and had come to Rome to arrange several matters connected with the convent in Vadstena which her mother had founded.  But St. Karin of Vadstena, as the Swedes called her, blankly refused to visit Queen Joanna…Karin Ulfsdotter was now a woman of about forty, but she was obviously convinced that there was no misdeed so terrible that Queen Joanna would not commit it.  If she and Catherine of Siena went to Naples they risked being taken in ambushed on the way and killed.  Raimondo agreed with Karin; he considered Queen Joanna an utterly depraved woman, and was stubbornly set against his “mamma” meeting her.  Only Catherine scorned her friends’ lack of courage….But Urban thought over what Karin said and let the idea drop.  (275-6)

Still to be considered for such a diplomatic mission is extraordinary and speaks of her reputation.  It also shows how dangerous it was for Catherine to do all the travels across Italy and France that she did.  Catherine had already implored Queen Joanna concerning the schism prior to this and would do so again.


While she was still in Siena Catherine had written to Queen Joanna—a passionate plea for the lawful Pope, Urban, to whom all Christian princes owed their loyalty.  From Rome she sent the Queen a letter which was even more outspoken.  She addresses the letter to her “dear mother in Christ.”  (Joanna was by then a woman of fifty-one and married for the fourth time.)  Catherine now writes to this woman on her favorite theme, self-love opposed to the love for God as He has revealed Himself in Christ Crucified.  “Oh, dear mother, you must love the Truth, you must submit yourself to the Holy Church—for otherwise I will never again call you mother or turn towards you with respect.  From being a queen you have been made a servant and the slave of something which is nothing…”  (277)

I would have loved to have been privy to Queen Joanna’s thoughts as she read from some commoner woman asking to consider herself a servant and slave.  I have not read much other writing from the time but I can’t imagine anyone else writing such as this.  Undset continues on Catherine’s letter.

 

Catherine begs Joanna at least to remain neutral until she has discovered the truth.  “Oh, I say to you in the deepest sorrow, for I wish with my whole soul that you may be saved, that if you do not change, and turn from this error and all others, the Highest Judge will punish you in such a way that it will fill all who think of rebelling against the Church with terror, do not wait for Him to strike, for it is hard to withstand God’s justice.  You must die, and you do not know when.”…Joanna paid no attention to Catherine’s warnings, not to those of the Pope.  (277-8) 

Joanna would ultimately be killed about four years later by the relations of her first husband, who it was said she had killed.  One could read about her in the Wikipedia entry.  She probably deserves a little more sympathy than suggested here when one takes the totality of her life in perspective.  She was living in a world of dangerous Italian politics and she was a woman, perhaps vulnerable to some degree.    

I can’t say I have fully grasped the subtleties of the schism.  Supporting Pope Urban we have the Dominican St. Catherine of Siena, and yet across Europe we have another Dominican who would become a saint, St. Vincent Ferrer  who supported the antipope (that is actually the title) Clement VII.  It shows you that elections are very dangerous if people don’t trust the process.  That should be a lesson to us today and the need to show the public that irregularities are addressed. 

Catherine also wrote a letter to three cardinals who apparently betrayed Urban and join the antipope.

 

It is possible that a letter from Catherine to the three Italian [cardinals] caused them to hesitate.  She begins by telling them that if they come out of the darkness in which they live she will call them her fathers, but not if they do not change their opinions.  The Sister of Penitence speaks sharply and to the point to the cardinals, as one who has authority.  Even her favorite theme of two kinds of love, the one life-giving, the other bringing death, is turned into a violent attack against these men who have been invested with the greatest responsibility and the highest dignities in the Church, but have become traitors through love of temporal things.  (280)

One should be respectful of our bishops and even our Pope, but one should also take Catherine’s example and speak truth to power.  She is amazing.  She even offers the pontiff advice.

 

Catherine had advised Pope Urban most urgently to collect around himself a lifeguard of the most worthy, righteous and pure of God’s servants—the same advice she had given his predecessor.  The Pope listened to her advice, or perhaps he had himself the same idea.  Now he wrote to the prior of the Carthusians at Gorgona and asked him to arrange for Masses to be said and prayers offered in all the monasteries in Tuscany for the Pope’s cause.  He commanded the prior moreover to appear in Rome before the end of the month, for the Pope wished to consult with him and other holy and pious monks regarding the problems of the times.  Catherine sent her own letters with the Pope’s bull’s: she wrote to most of her old friends in the various monasteries, and also to the prior of Gorgona.  (282)

This is not mere tangential praying for the Pope’s cause.  It seems like she is working hand in hand with the Holy Father.  Undset in this narrative clearly delineates the relationship in this way.  She continues.


Urban was always loyal to Catherine.  He always thought seriously over what she suggested and advised, and he did not turn against her or become sulky, as Gregory XI had dine at times when it seemed as though he had got himself into a difficult position through following her advice.  The obstinate and headstrong old man never seems to have been offended at anything she wrote to him; he obviously felt real fatherly love for “this little woman” whom he allowed to lead him, and honored her as the chosen spokesman of his Lord and Master…Catherine and Urban looked exactly the same way at the most important questions of their time—the cleansing of the Church and the re-awakening of faith among all Christian peoples.  (283)

This is beyond any imagining of Catherine’s involvement in solving the schism.  She wasn’t exactly the Pope’s “chief of staff” but perhaps we can think of her as even more elevated than that.  She was almost an equal political figure, Urban at the head of the earthly faction, Catherine at the head of the spiritual faction.  Unfortunately Catherine died in 1380, and one wonders that had she lived a normal life span, she may have helped resolve this crises.  Urban the VI would live another ten years after Catherine’s death, and the schism still fully entrenched.  The schism would last until 1417 and include three more legitimate popes and four antipopes, and at one time three men claiming to be pope at the same time.  In all it was thirty-nine years of turmoil.  Clearly Catherine’s two or three years involvement were not superficial, and history really should reflect more of her efforts.