"Love follows knowledge."
"Beauty above all beauty!"
– St. Catherine of Siena

Sunday, March 12, 2023

Sunday Meditation: The Woman at the Well

Today Jesus reveals His divine nature again, only this time to the outside world.  Who is the recipient of such a blessing?  A woman, no less, and a Samaritan, the religious adversaries of the Jews.

 

 

Jesus came to a town of Samaria called Sychar,

near the plot of land that Jacob had given to his son Joseph.

Jacob’s well was there.

Jesus, tired from his journey, sat down there at the well.

It was about noon.

 

A woman of Samaria came to draw water.

Jesus said to her,

“Give me a drink.”

His disciples had gone into the town to buy food.

The Samaritan woman said to him,

“How can you, a Jew, ask me, a Samaritan woman, for a drink?”

—For Jews use nothing in common with Samaritans.—

Jesus answered and said to her,

“If you knew the gift of God

and who is saying to you, ‘Give me a drink, ‘

you would have asked him

and he would have given you living water.”

The woman said to him,

“Sir, you do not even have a bucket and the cistern is deep;

where then can you get this living water?

Are you greater than our father Jacob,

who gave us this cistern and drank from it himself

with his children and his flocks?”

Jesus answered and said to her,

“Everyone who drinks this water will be thirsty again;

but whoever drinks the water I shall give will never thirst;

the water I shall give will become in him

a spring of water welling up to eternal life.”

The woman said to him,

“Sir, give me this water, so that I may not be thirsty

or have to keep coming here to draw water.”

 

Jesus said to her,

“Go call your husband and come back.”

The woman answered and said to him,

“I do not have a husband.”

Jesus answered her,

“You are right in saying, ‘I do not have a husband.’

For you have had five husbands,

and the one you have now is not your husband.

What you have said is true.”

The woman said to him,

“Sir, I can see that you are a prophet.

Our ancestors worshiped on this mountain;

but you people say that the place to worship is in Jerusalem.”

Jesus said to her,

“Believe me, woman, the hour is coming

when you will worship the Father

neither on this mountain nor in Jerusalem.

You people worship what you do not understand;

we worship what we understand,

because salvation is from the Jews.

But the hour is coming, and is now here,

when true worshipers will worship the Father in Spirit and truth;

and indeed the Father seeks such people to worship him.

God is Spirit, and those who worship him

must worship in Spirit and truth.”

The woman said to him,

“I know that the Messiah is coming, the one called the Christ;

when he comes, he will tell us everything.”

Jesus said to her,

“I am he, the one speaking with you.”

 

At that moment his disciples returned,

and were amazed that he was talking with a woman,

but still no one said, “What are you looking for?”

or “Why are you talking with her?”

The woman left her water jar

and went into the town and said to the people,

“Come see a man who told me everything I have done.

Could he possibly be the Christ?”

They went out of the town and came to him.

Meanwhile, the disciples urged him, “Rabbi, eat.”

But he said to them,

“I have food to eat of which you do not know.”

So the disciples said to one another,

“Could someone have brought him something to eat?”

Jesus said to them,

“My food is to do the will of the one who sent me

and to finish his work.

Do you not say, ‘In four months the harvest will be here’?

I tell you, look up and see the fields ripe for the harvest.

The reaper is already receiving payment

and gathering crops for eternal life,

so that the sower and reaper can rejoice together.

For here the saying is verified that ‘One sows and another reaps.’

I sent you to reap what you have not worked for;

others have done the work,

and you are sharing the fruits of their work.”

 

Many of the Samaritans of that town began to believe in him

because of the word of the woman who testified,

“He told me everything I have done.”

When the Samaritans came to him,

 

they invited him to stay with them;

and he stayed there two days.

Many more began to believe in him because of his word,

and they said to the woman,

“We no longer believe because of your word;

for we have heard for ourselves,

and we know that this is truly the savior of the world.”

~Jn 5:4-52

  

Here is a wonderful dramatization from the series The Chosen. 

 

 

Here is an explanation from the producers of The Chosen.

 


This is one of my favorite stories too.  Let us drink the Living Water in Spirit and Truth!

Thursday, March 9, 2023

George MacDonald: My Little King, Part 2

This is the second post of George MacDonald’s collect of Christmas poems and short stories under the book title, My Little King.

You can read Post #1, on the poem, “A Christmas Carol,” here.  



 

This post will focus on the short story, “The Gifts of the Child Christ.”  You can read the story online at The Literature Network, here.  Or you can hear it being read through Librovox.

 


The following summary was put together in collaboration with my co-moderator at the Catholic Thought Book Club, Kerstin.

Summary

 

Mr. Greatorex is a widower of about 30 and remarried. The couple is unhappy. He has a daughter from his previous marriage, Sophy, who is neglected by the couple and most of the household. Even her nurse, Alice, is pre-occupied with the prospect of inheriting a large sum of money.

 

Sophy is a pious child. Their preacher has a recurring theme in his Sunday sermons, “the chastening of the Lord”, which makes a deep impression on her innocent mind. She wishes that the Lord would chasten her.

 

Mrs. Greatorex is pregnant and on Christmas night she gives birth to a stillborn boy. Early in the morning the household finds Sophy with her lifeless brother on her lap in a Pietà–like position.

 

In a parallel sub-plot, Alice, the  Greatorex’s servant, anticipates a large inheritance from her uncle and leaves the service of the Greatorexes. Her new found wealth creates a change in her that now she feels above her fiance John and breaks up with him. In a twist of the plot, her “inheritance” turns out to be a ruse, and now 'chastened', returns to John and her employers. She will be at the Greatorex’s home when the stillborn child is found.

###

Celia Commented:

This story, though sad, does end up on a positive note. Especially noteworthy is Sophy's attitude about Christmas: she is looking for the Christ Child, not presents. A very wise 9 year old.

My Reply to Celia:

I thought Sophy was five years old. Where did you see nine?

Celia’s Reply:

I looked again and she is 7.  How did I get Sophy's age? From this excerpt.

 

"Some six years before, he had married to please his parents; and a year before, he had married to please himself."

 

I assume Sophy is 7, maybe 6.

Kerstin Commented:

Now we have to tie in how the "chastening of the Lord" fits in.

 

Sophy, who is the most innocent of all and desires this correction - even though she may not even understand what is meant here - really has no need of it. It is the family around her who have fallen into dysfunctional behavior patterns.

 

Mr. and Mrs. Greatorex live parallel lives, they are absorbed and closed off to each other with their own selfishness. It is not a relationship of mutual giving. The repercussions of this self-isolation is spilling over in how they neglect Sophy.

 

Alice is so self-absorbed and blinded by the promise of monetary riches and social status that she no longer recognizes the intangible riches of marrying a good man.

 

It is a household barren of love. Letty's child dies because there is no love, the self-giving necessary to nurture life. It is fitting that all this happens during Christmas night, for during this night Love is born. The coming of the Savior marks a demarcation line of what was before and what comes after. Only now can Love break in and heal this family from their self-destruction. But there is a real cost too. The sins of this previous life truly happened, and the pain and suffering they brought need to be transformed and redeemed. Sophy's Pietà–like posture points to this.

###

My Comment:

I think everyone has mentioned all the bright spots of the story. Let me mention a couple of negatives.

 

(1) The baby was relatively a surprise. You have to search to find that Letty might even be pregnant. There is no detail of of Letty's pregnancy. The most I could find is that she wanted to give her husband a son.

 

(2) Where is any detail of the birth? If the baby was still born, who cleaned it up? Where were the post birth fluids? Was the baby still born or just died in infancy? I cannot tell. At first I thought Sophy had smothered it by accident. But that couldn't be it.

 

(3) Once the dead baby has been found, where is the horror and shock? For a moment Alice runs to her boyfriend crying, but once the baby is taken away, they have a conversation about her inheritance as if nothing has happened. There was a dead baby in the room moments before and they are talking about inheritance?

 

(4) Where is Letty's reaction to the dead baby? She's in her room crying and when her husband comes in and sooths her, it's all alright, just like that? It's all ok after an hour or two?

 

I found the ending of the story bizarre and lacking and really unclear in detail.

My Comment:

This is not a criticism, but something I can't understand how it fits. The name "Greatorex" is unusual, definitely not an English/Scottish name, and almost certainly contrived to have some significance. But what? "Rex" is Latin for king. So "Great king"? Why? Ironic? Alluding to the king who will be born at Christmas?

Kerstin Replied:

I was wondering about this too. If it is a play on words, were they making themselves greater than God?

Keith Replied:

Hello everyone. Just joining in this read. I wonder if the almost casual nature of the response to the baby’s death reflects how much more common it was in the 19th century for babies to die at birth or to be born dead.

 

And perhaps the reticence about Letty’s pregnancy and the specifics of the birth reflects how one did not speak of such things in those days. I wonder how MacDonald speaks of pregnancy in his other works? This is the first I’ve read of his.

My Reply to Keith:

Well, that could be about infant mortality being more common then. It's still rather bizarre to me. I thought about the reticence of bodily things in Victorian times, but still there has to be some detail, even if it's oblique or a euphemism. I didn't see any.

Kerstin Replied:

George MacDonald was a protestant minister. Six of his eleven children died before he did, five in infancy. Looking at the passage more closely, I think we find that the tragedy that has befallen the Greatorex household is felt very keenly.

 

Her mistress was again taken ill. Doctor and nurse were sent for in hot haste; hansom cabs came and went throughout the night, like noisy moths to the one lighted house in the street; there were soft steps within, and doors were gently opened and shut. The waters of Mara had risen and filled the house.

 

Towards morning they were ebbing slowly away. Letty did not know that her husband was watching by her bedside. The street was quiet now. So was the house. Most of its people had been up throughout the night, but now they had all gone to bed except the strange nurse and Mr. Greatorex.

 

The “waters of Mara” are out of Exodus 15:22 – 27. Israel had just crossed the Red Sea and they couldn’t find any fresh water for three days. Then at Marah the water they found was bitter. Moses threw a piece of wood into the water and it was made fresh. This reference not only points at the Passion, but is also about suffering at its most dire, the lack of life-giving water.

My Reply to Kerstin:

Yes, I remember reading that. Did anyone realize she was pregnant then? I think she was ill frequently in the story but it went unexplained.

 

That's an interesting detail from MacDonald's bio. Yes, I can see how he might be projecting into the scene.

 

By criticizing the casualness of the baby's death in the story, I don't mean to imply that MacDonald was not compassionate to babies dying. I'm criticizing the way he rushed to conclude his story. It felt he was just trying to bring it to a close and provided a simplified wrapping up of the story.

Kerstin Replied:

I had a hunch Liddy was pregnant, though it wasn't confirmed until Sophy finds the baby. Her not feeling well again - for a young married woman that usually means morning sickness - and then the activity going on in the house during the night, made me wonder.



###

My Comment:

So here’s an interesting question.  The story is titled “The Gifts of the Christ Child.”  Now who is the “Christ child”?  Is it simply the Christ whose birth they are celebrating?  Is it Sophy?  Is it the dead baby?

 

Certainly it’s Christmas Day, so baby Jesus does enter the scene metaphysically.  But I think you could make the case that both Sophy and the dead baby are Christ figure types.

 

The dead baby is probably most obvious.  Sophy’s discovery of the child is worth quoting.

 

The room next the foot of the stair, and opposite her step-mother's, was the spare room, with which she associated ideas of state and grandeur: where better could she begin than at the guest-chamber?—There!—Could it be? Yes!—Through the chink of the scarce-closed door she saw light. Either he was already there or there they were expecting him. From that moment she felt as if lifted out of the body. Far exalted above all dread, she peeped modestly in, and then entered. Beyond the foot of the bed, a candle stood on a little low table, but nobody was to be seen. There was a stool near the table: she would sit on it by the candle, and wait for him. But ere she reached it, she caught sight of something upon the bed that drew her thither. She stood entranced.—Could it be?—It might be. Perhaps he had left it there while he went into her mamma's room with something for her.—The loveliest of dolls ever imagined! She drew nearer. The light was low, and the shadows were many: she could not be sure what it was. But when she had gone close up to it, she concluded with certainty that it was in very truth a doll—perhaps intended for her—but beyond doubt the most exquisite of dolls. She dragged a chair to the bed, got, up, pushed her little arms softly under it, and drawing it gently to her, slid down with it. When she felt her feet firm on the floor, filled with the solemn composure of holy awe she carried the gift of the child Jesus to the candle, that she might the better admire its beauty and know its preciousness. But the light had no sooner fallen upon it than a strange undefinable doubt awoke within her. Whatever it was, it was the very essence of loveliness—the tiny darling with its alabaster face, and its delicately modelled hands and fingers! A long night-gown covered all the rest.—Was it possible?—Could it be?—Yes, indeed! it must be—it could be nothing else than a real baby! What a goose she had been! Of course it was baby Jesus himself!—for was not this his very own Christmas Day on which he was always born?—If she had felt awe of his gift before, what a grandeur of adoring love, what a divine dignity possessed her, holding in her arms the very child himself! One shudder of bliss passed through her, and in an agony of possession she clasped the baby to her great heart—then at once became still with the satisfaction of eternity, with the peace of God. She sat down on the stool, near the little table, with her back to the candle, that its rays should not fall on the eyes of the sleeping Jesus and wake him: there she sat, lost in the very majesty of bliss, at once the mother and the slave of the Lord Jesus.

 

That is perhaps the best written passage in the entire story.  The baby is described in Christ allusions: “Through the chink of the scarce-closed door she saw light.”  “…she concluded with certainty that it was in very truth a doll…”  “…filled with the solemn composure of holy awe she carried the gift of the child Jesus to the candle…”  “Of course it was baby Jesus himself!—for was not this his very own Christmas Day on which he was always born?”  “If she had felt awe of his gift before, what a grandeur of adoring love, what a divine dignity possessed her…”  “then at once became still with the satisfaction of eternity, with the peace of God…” and finally, “there she sat, lost in the very majesty of bliss, at once the mother and the slave of the Lord Jesus.” 

 

And then when Sophy awakes to realize the dead baby, she proclaims Christ’s death.

 

“Jesus is dead,” she said, slowly and sadly, but with perfect calmness. “He is dead,” she repeated. “He came too early, and there was no one up to take care of him, and he’s dead—dead—dead!”

 

The thrice pronouncement of “dead—dead—dead” echoes the thrice incantation of the Agnus Dei.  It’s a reference to Christ’s sacrifice and the redemption of the world.  Through the baby’s death, all the characters are redeemed.

 

So how is Sophy a Christ figure? 

 

But she did not read far: her thoughts went back to a phrase which had haunted her ever since first she went to church: "Whom the Lord loveth, he chasteneth."

 

Later she thinks, “I wish he would chasten me.”  To chasten is “to correct by punishment or suffering.”  (Webster’s Dictionary) with the connotation of purifying.  And frequently she says, "If the Lord would but chasten me!"  The frequency of Sophy’s wish to be chastened is a leitmotif, a recurring phrase that accompanies her and characterizes her.  When Alice is struggling because of her humiliation, Sophy turns to her: "Is the Lord chastening Alice? I wish he would chasten Phosy."  Sophy becomes the “suffering servant,” taking on the sins of the world, or at least those around her.  And so when she sits with the lifeless baby she associates with being chastened:

 

 She sat for a time still as marble waiting for marble to awake, heedful as tenderest woman not to rouse him before his time, though her heart was swelling with the eager petition that he would ask his Father to be as good as chasten her. And as she sat, she began, after her wont, to model her face to the likeness of his, that she might understand his stillness—the absolute peace that dwelt on his countenance.

 

She for a moment becomes Jesus.  Indeed through Sophy her father is transformed.

 

And every day, as he looked in her face and talked to her, it was with more and more respect for what he found in her, with growing tenderness for her predilections, and reverence for the divine idea enclosed in her ignorance, for her childish wisdom, and her calm seeking—until at length he would have been horrified at the thought of training her up in his way: had she not a way of her own to go—following—not the dead Jesus, but Him who liveth for evermore?

 

Her childish wisdom is divine wisdom.  She too is a child Christ.




Sunday, March 5, 2023

Sunday Meditation: Matthew’s Transfiguration

Today Jesus reveals His divine nature.  We have one of the most iconic moments of the New Testament, the Transfiguration.  All three Synoptic Gospels tell of this moment.  In Year A of the lectionary, we have Matthew’s version.

 

Jesus took Peter, James, and John his brother,

and led them up a high mountain by themselves.

And he was transfigured before them;

his face shone like the sun

and his clothes became white as light.

And behold, Moses and Elijah appeared to them,

conversing with him.

Then Peter said to Jesus in reply,

"Lord, it is good that we are here.

If you wish, I will make three tents here,

one for you, one for Moses, and one for Elijah."

While he was still speaking, behold,

a bright cloud cast a shadow over them,

then from the cloud came a voice that said,

"This is my beloved Son, with whom I am well pleased;

listen to him."

When the disciples heard this, they fell prostrate

and were very much afraid.

But Jesus came and touched them, saying,

"Rise, and do not be afraid."

And when the disciples raised their eyes,

they saw no one else but Jesus alone.

 

As they were coming down from the mountain,

Jesus charged them,

"Do not tell the vision to anyone

until the Son of Man has been raised from the dead."

~Mt 17:1-9

  

Last year, I posted Dr. Brant Pitre explaining the transfiguration as told in Luke’s Gospel.  Here he is again explaining it as told in Matthew’s Gospel.

 


There is a lot there to really sink your teeth into.  But I want to end this with one of the great representations of the event, Fra Angelico’s The Transfiguration.

 

 

Notice how Christ is delineated at about twice the size of the three apostles fallen to the ground.  And the blazing white of Christ’s figure is almost blinding.  Christ’s arms are spread out projecting the crucifixion and we see the heads of Moses and Elijah on each side.  I love the delineation of Christ’s face as you can see in this detail.

 


His expression is emotionless and He is thickly bearded, depicted I think as one who has taken “the vow of a Nazirite” (see Numbers, chapter 6).  And consider the detail of the apostles at Jesus’ feet. 

 


The one facing the viewer would have to be Peter with the sash I think signifying authority.  He is turned away from Christ, projecting Peter’s denial of Jesus.  The apostles are not clothed in white garments.  That is reserved for Jesus, and I would guess that the apostle with the blondish hair is John since the hair makes him look youngish.

Who are those two figures on the sides looking in at Jesus?  On the right is St. Dominic.  Fra Angelico was a Dominican friar.  On the left is said to be the Virgin Mary. 

Friday, March 3, 2023

What to Make of the Asbury Revival

Perhaps you’ve heard of the religious spiritual phenomena—or should I call it a religious experience?—that occurred at Asbury University from February 8th to the 21st just a few weeks ago, referred to as the Asbury Revival .  You can read about it here.  I’m not sure what to make of it.  Let me say up front that I tend to be skeptical of even Catholic supernatural events.  (I’m sorry, but I find it impossible to believe that Padre Pio bi-located.)  Did the Holy Spirit come to the Protestant college to bring about this awakening?  I’m not going to say no, but my natural skepticism doesn’t let me dive right into this belief. 

It should be noted that Asbury University is associated with the Methodist and Wesleyan-Holiness tradition, which believes in personal holiness and sanctification.  Wesleyan Protestantism was in many ways antithetical to the Lutheran and Calvinist notions against works for salvation.  John Wesley agreed with Protestant Arminianism, which denounced the predestination of the Calvinists.  On this theological issue Jacobus Arminius and John Wesley were heading back toward a Catholic notion of sanctification and salvation.  So if these students at Asbury University were practicing spiritual holiness, I could see how they may have tapped into something mystical. 

Still I don’t know how much is this self-induced spirituality, which is what I see in Pentecostal experiences, both Protestant and Catholic Pentecostalism.  I’m not saying anyone at these Pentecostal (again both Protestant and Catholic, and I’ve been to at least one Catholic Pentecostal Mass with follow-on healing service) events are faking their experiences.  I just think there is a psychological state these people put themselves in that feels like they are receiving direct interaction with the Holy Spirit.  And to clarify, I’m also not saying they aren’t receiving any graces from the Lord in that state.  They may well be.  The evidence of grace will be the fruits of their lives.  But are they really responding to the Holy Spirit? 

Now here’s an interesting little detail from the Wikipedia entry on 2023 Asbury Revival.  When you look into the background of Asbury University and revivals, the “University has a history of revivals, dating back in 1905, 1908, 1921, 1950, 1958, 1970, 1992, and 2006.”  What?  This is the ninth revival in 120 years at the same college?  Is the Holy Spirit then singling out Asbury University or is the college campus subculture one where there is a predisposition for revivals from identity to its heritage?  Now this doesn’t mean the phenomena is not legit.  The Holy Spirit is more likely going to come to those who ask, but it does raise questions.

Enough of my skepticism.  There is a Catholic response to the Revival and it’s not skepticism.  I’ve seen positive comments across the Catholic world, and I can’t say I’ve seen any skeptical.  Apparently even a Catholic priest or two partly participated during the thirteen days it went on.  Here is the EWTN news show, In Depth, reporting and interviewing on the phenomena.  Only the first fifteen minutes concern the Revival.



And then I found a “Catholic Response” to the Asbury Revival, specifically from Fr. Ignatius Schweitzer, O.P..  Let me say I happen to tangentially (I haven’t met him in person yet, only through Zoom) know Fr. Ignatius.  He is the Provincial Priest of the Province of my Lay Dominican chapter.   Now in my opinion he strikes me as a bit different than your typical contemporary Dominican priest.  He is much more into the mystical tradition than the stereotypical Dominican philosopher.  The Dominicans do have a mystical tradition, but it mostly goes back to the 14th and 15th centuries (St. Catherine of Siena, Meister Eckhart, Henry Susso, and others).  If you search on YouTube for Fr. Ignatius, a number of videos will come up put out by the Dominican House of Prayer with Fr. Ignatius explaining the mystics and their works.  So this spiritual phenomena is part of his expertise.  Here is Fr. Ignatius’ Catholic Response to the Asbury Revival.

 



He reminds me more of a Carmelite than a Dominican, and he brings up Carmelite saints often.  Let me also add, if you wondered, that he is definitely orthodox and not one of the liberals trying to change the faith.  I was also surprised to find him interviewed on Edify today.  Coincidences again!  Edify is a conservative Catholic podcast associated with Catholic Vote, with a focus on news and cultural issues.  Today’s episode, “Revival through the Eucharist,” host Mary FioRito interviews Fr. Ignatius. 

 


Now, I’ve given you my more skeptical view of the Asbury Revival, and I’ve given you the more endorsing view by Fr. Ignatius.  What do you make of it?  Any thoughts?