Completed:
The Sorrows of Young
Werther, a novel by Johan
Wolfgang von Goethe.
“Give Me Your Heart,” a
short story by Joyce Carol Oates.
“The Triumph of Night,”
a short story by Edith Wharton.
Not God’s Type: A
Rational Academic Finds a Radical Faith, a non-fiction memoir by Holly Ordway.
“Master Misery,” a short
story by Truman Capote.
Jesus of Nazareth: The
Infancy Narratives, a non-fiction book of
theology by Pope Benedict XVI.
“Bartleby the Scrivener:
A Story of Wall Street,” a short story by Herman Melville.
The Book of Job, a book of the Old Testament, KJV Translation.
“Little Miracles, Kept
Promises,” a short story by Sandra Cisneros.
“The Portobello Road,” a
short story by Muriel Spark.
Orthodoxy, a non-fiction book of philosophy by G. K.
Chesterton.
“Queen of the Tyrant
Lizards,” a short story by John C. Wright.
“The Key,” a short story
by Eudora Welty.
“Extricating Young
Gussie,” a Jeeves Collection short story P. G. Wodehouse.
Vol 2 of Les
Misérables, “Cosette,” a novel by Victor Hugo.
“An Alpine Idyll,” a
short story by Ernest Hemingway.
Dare We Hope that All
Men be Saved? With a Short Discourse on Hell, a non-fiction work of theology by Hans Urs von Balthasar.
“Henry Lee Remembers
George Washington,” from Lend Me Your Ears: Great Speeches in History,
selected by William Safire.
“A Pursuit Race,” a
short story by Ernest Hemingway.
“Today is Friday,” a
short story by Ernest Hemingway.
ASPCA Complete Guide to
Cats: Everything You Need to Know About Choosing and Caring for Your Pet, a non-fiction work by James Richards.
“Banal Story,” a short
story by Ernest Hemingway.
Maggie: A Girl of the
Streets, a novella by Stephen
Crane.
Feline Catastrophe, a collection of short stories by Victor S E Moubarak.
“Now I Lay Me,” a short
story by Ernest Hemingway.
“Sounds,” a short story
by Vladimir Nabokov.
Crime and Punishment, a novel by Fyodor Dostoevsky.
“The Quest,” a short
story by Saki (H. H. Munro).
“Tobermory,” a short
story by Saki (H. H. Munro).
“Mrs. Packletide’s
Tiger,” a short story by Saki (H. H. Munro).
“The Secret Sin of
Septimus Brope,” a short story by Saki (H. H. Munro).
“The Sisters,” a short
story by James Joyce.
No More Parades, the 2nd novel of the Parade’s End
Tetralogy by Ford Madox Ford.
Death in the Afternoon:
Meditations on the Last Seven Words of Jesus from the Cross, a non-fiction work of theology by Richard John
Neuhaus.
Comedy of Errors, a play by William Shakespeare.
“The Human Fly,” a short
story by T. C. Boyle.
Robert Lowell: Collected
Poems, an anthology of poetry
edited by Frank Bidart and David Gewanter.
Psalms 1-50 from The
Book of Psalms, a book of the Old Testament, KJV and Ignatius RSV Translations.
Unfinished Reading:
Julius Caesar: Life of a Colossus, a biography by Adrian Goldsworthy.
The Book of Psalms, a book of the Old Testament, KJV and Ignatius RSV
Translations.
Artful Sentences: Syntax as Style, a non-fiction book on writing by Virginia Tufte.
Let
me start by saying that this was not a good year for my reading, though as I
put together this summary it turned out to be not as disastrous as I had
speculated. Here are the links to the
various milestone updates I provided:
As
you can see, there was no Third Quarter Update, which would have come sometime
after the end of September. Between the
end of June and the October was almost a black hole of reading, and so I did
not feel a quarterly update was warranted.
What happened? I started Crime and Punishment somewhere while I
was on vacation in that last week of June, but after vacation my reading was
completely sporadic. It had nothing to
do with the novel—it was a great and intense read. I read it in spurts, which means I had gaps
where I did not pick it up. In these
gaps I did pick up a few less mind consuming reads, but I was kind of burnt out
over the summer. I guess I can give
excuses: we now had a cat to go along with the dog, which required adapting, this
dog was and still is more time consuming than past dogs, Matthew was a year
older and now needs more attention, the baseball season preoccupied me more
than other summers, and I had one of those intense periods at work where a
project was culminating. Sigh, I just
couldn’t keep up with my plans.
In
the end, though, I approximated my usual average number of reads. But it’s somewhat deceiving. Though the completion numbers were not far
from average, the works tended to be on the shorter side, so if I were to
calculate the number of pages read I don’t think I came close to average. But I don’t know what my average number of
pages read per year would be. Last year
I estimated I read somewhere over 4300 pages.
This year I estimate I read about 3600 pages, a good 700 pages less than
last year.
Perhaps
I should start with what I had intended to read and never got done. The fiction works, I had planned to read were
Dante’s Paradisio, Thomas Mann’s Buddenbrooks, Virginia Woolf’s To The Lighthouse, Thomas Berger’s Crazy in Berlin, and D. H. Lawrence’s The Virgin and the Gypsy. I had intended to have a German literature
theme to the 2015 reads, but I only got a few of the German works I planned
read. I am embarrassed to say that for
the second year I did not complete the Adrian Goldsworthy Julius Caesar biography. I
was about a hundred pages in at the end of last year and I read another 200
pages this year. 200 more pages to go:
do you think I’ll finish it this year?
That’s sarcasm. It’s a really
good biography. I also didn’t finish my
one work on writing that I read every year, this year being Virginia Tufte’s Artful Sentences: Syntax as Style. I’m about 40 percent through, and it is fine
work. It shows you how to use every
element of grammar to craft fine sentences.
I’m going to post a few times this year on various things that caught my
attention from this book. I only read
the first third of the Psalms. I have to
say I got caught up on how I should analyze and categorize them, and wound up
letting perfection tie me up in knots. I
should have just read them. And since I
didn’t finish the Psalms, I never got to the two Epistles to the
Corinthians. Even under the best of
conditions, I could never have completed all I planned.
Interestingly
and not intentional, the novels I completed had a 19th century
bias. Four of the five works were from
the 19th century, and they were all what would be deemed classic
novels: von Goethe’s The Sorrows of Young
Werther, Volume 2 of Hugo’s Les
Misérables, “Cosette” (I’m treating each volume as a separate novel in this
huge tome), Dostoyevsky’s Crime and
Punishment, and Crane’s short novel, Maggie:
A Girl of the Streets. Crane’s Maggie was a disappointment. I believe it was his first novel, and it
showed. Though there were moments of
brilliant prose, it was not up to his more well-known works. Unless you’re a Stephan Crane scholar or
aficionado, I don’t recommend it.
Goethe’s Young Werther was
also his first novel, and though I could quibble with elements of the work,
overall it was enjoyable and interesting.
It was a huge international sensation in its day, one of the foundations
of the Romantic era, and so an important work to have read if one wants to
complete the important works of literature.
Les Misérables and Crime and Punishment are also important
works, but they are truly great works.
Dostoyevsky’s novel just could be rated in the top five of the greatest
novels ever written, which would give Dostoyevsky two of the greatest novels
ever written. The one work not of the 19th
century was Ford Madox Ford’s No More
Parades, which is the second novel of his tetralogy, Parade’s End. This is a very
modernist work (stream of conscious, time dislocations, psychological theories,
disjointed narrative), and you have to enjoy modernism to like this novel. It’s difficult but worth it if you enjoy high
artistry in literature.
I
had made it a goal to read more non-fiction works in 2015, and I did; I read
six, more than the novels. Three of the
non-fiction works were theological works, all of them excellent: Pope Benedict
XVI’s third in his series on Jesus of Nazareth, The Infancy Narratives, Richard John Neuhaus’ Death in the Afternoon, and Hans Urs von Bathalsar’s, Dare We Hope All Men Be Saved. I have to say that all three are great
theologians, offering incredible insight.
The Infancy Narratives focus
on just that, the Christ child sections of the New Testament, Death in the Afternoon focus on the
seven last words of Christ on the cross, and von Balthasar’s book delves on the
possibility that salvation is universal, meaning that eventually everyone could
be saved. Urs von Balthasar took a lot
of criticism for this very controversial position. The Catholic Church, as most Christian
denominations, do not support such a notion.
I have to say that I have always been sympathetic to the notion of universalism,
and this book reinforced my thinking.
I’ve been meaning to write a detailed essay on the subject, but I don’t
know if I want to be so controversial. I
never planned at the beginning of the year to read the Neuhaus and the von
Balthasar but things happen that inspire me to improvise.
Also
as a non-fiction read was G. K. Chesterton’s brilliant philosophic work, Orthodoxy. Its central theme is that tradition and the
western intellectual heritage is the proper basis philosophic
underpinnings. It stands in complete
opposition to modernism. This is a must
read for anyone interested in the intellectual development of the 20th
century, no matter which side of the issue you stand on, and it has all the
Chesterton hallmarks of sharpness and humor. Holly Ordway’s Not God’s Type is a memoir conversion
story of how Ordway went from being a fierce atheist to a believing Christian,
and she did through her love of literature.
It was a really enjoyable read.
Finally since in May we found and adopted a little kitten, and since we
had no experience raising cats, I read the ASPCA’s
Complete Guide to Cats. That was
unplanned.
I
did not read the entire tome of Robert Lowell’s Collected Poetry, nor did I intend to at the beginning of the
year. I did read enough to sample
through and enjoy his most famous poems.
I posted on four of his poems throughout the year, and I think you would
appreciate his work by reading those posts.
At the end of December I snuck in William Shakespeare’s The Comedy of Errors, which is one of
his earliest plays, shortest plays, and funniest plays. It was a play I had never read before, and so
I have now read 27 of the 37 officially accredited plays to Shakespeare. I had not clicked off one in a few
years. It’s one of my goals to read them
all. As to my annual Biblical reads, I
read the Book of Job (KJV) and the first fifty Psalms (KJV and Ignatius RSV
translations). The Book of Psalms is so
rich that I read it in two translations and I decided I wanted to learn them in
a much more detailed way than just a read through. I tried hand copying each Psalm into a
notebook, but after the first 19 I realize it would take forever. I did pick up a lot of nuance by hand writing
down each word, nuance that you gloss over as one reads. Since that was too time consuming, I’ve
decided to create a database of types, themes, length, and important images and
phrases Psalm by Psalm. Perhaps that
will be more fruitful.
I
meant to read several famous speeches from history this year from Safire’s Lend Me Your Ears, but I only
read one, Henry Lee’s eulogy of George Washington. I enjoyed it, and one gets to observe great
speech craft, the art of oration. A
speech is roughly the length of a short story.
Another work I read that doesn’t easily fit into a category was Victor Moubarak’s Feline Catastrophe. You may have noticed that Victor is a
frequent visitor to this blog, and I have now read a couple of his books. Feline
Catastrophe is a collection of fictional vignettes centered on a house
cat. The cat outwits the master at every
turn. It’s hilarious, and well worth a
read. It’s one of those books I needed
to have as break when I was burnt out from intense literature. I think you can get it for free as a PDF at
his website.
I
read twenty-one short stories this year, which was only three short of my
annual goal of two per month. But since
the Henry Lee speech was approximately the length of a short story, then I was
only two short. Still, these short
stories were mostly on the shorter side which makes it look more impressive
than it really is. There were a number
of authors I had never read before: Wright, Spark, Wodehouse, Boyle, all very
good writers with distinct styles. I
hope in the future to read more of their work.
The short stories can be classified as good, exceptional, or duds. There were three duds in the group that I
would tell you don’t ever bother: Joyce Carol Oats’ “Give Me Your Heart,” Edith Wharton’s “The
Triumph of the Night,” and Hemingway’s “Today is Friday.” The exceptional were Melville’s “Bartleby the
Scrivener,” Spark’s “The Portobello Road,” Welty’s “The Key,” two by Hemingway,
“An Alpine Idyll,” and “Now I Lay Me,” Nabokov’s “Sounds,” Joyce’s “The
Sisters,” Boyle’s “The Human Fly,” and two
by Saki, “Tobermory” and “The Secret Sin of Septimus Brope.” There were four stories by Saki in the year’s
read and one could make a case that all four could make the exceptional
category. It probably depends on my
impulse of the moment. He’s that good a
short story writer. “Bartleby the
Scrivener” and “The Sisters” were both stories I had read in the past and are
classics. It’s always good to re-read a
few classics every year. You tend to see
so much more. Throughout the year I
posted analyzes on “The Portobello Road,” “The Key,” Now I Lay Me,” and
“Tobermory.” You can find them by
scrolling down the Labels list. I read
five stories from Hemingway, as I make my way through his entire
collection. I’ve now read more than two
thirds. T. C. Boyle is one of the
current top American short story writers and I really wanted to read one of his
stories. “The Human Fly” does not
disappoint, and I will try to do one of my analyses on it in the near
future. “Sounds” is my third or possibly
fourth Vladimir Nabokov short story that I’ve read. What is notable about all the Nabokov stories
I’ve read so far is that they are perfection in form and style. There isn’t a word out of place; they are economic
in delineation, and perfectly structured.
He may be the most skilled fiction writer I have ever read.
So which of the stories
gets the annual prize for best read story of the year? Of the exceptional listed above, I would say…drum
roll please… Let’s Start with the honorable mentions and runner’s up: Muriel Spark’s
“The Portobello Road,” and Ernest Hemingway’s “Now I Lay Me.” Both stories had nuance, depth, and created
an interesting experience for the reader.
The winner for 2015 is Herman Melville’s “Bartleby the Scrivener: A
Story of Wall Street.” There’s a reason
why “Bartleby” is a classic. The social implications, the psychological
insight, and the religious connotations make it a profound story, and Melville’s
prose is always sparkling.
Now one last thing, I
have to apologize to one of my commenters who had a request and I didn’t follow
through. A friend, Mary Sue, asked me back
in the spring to write up specific posts for Melville’s “Bartleby” and
Chesterton’s Orthodoxy. I said I would and I worked up thoughts for
both but never put pen to paper – or fingers to keyboard. Orthodoxy
is just too large to do. When sometime
in the future I read it again—and it’s worth another read—I’ll put together
some sort of detailed post. Since I can’t
renege twice to the same person, and since “Bartleby” won my annual best short
study read, I owe it to Mary Sue to post an analysis of it. So stay tuned for that Mary Sue.
If there is anything
that caught your eye in my 2015 Reads, let me know. I can discuss it further.