I
thought this was a joke at first, but it’s true. The Swedish Academy that selects Nobel Prizes
has had some quirks over its life, but this takes the cake. If you haven’t heard, this year’s winner of
the Nobel Prize in Literature—yes, Literature—is none other than Bob
Dylan. From NBC News:
Bob Dylan was awarded the
Nobel Prize in literature on Thursday.
The 75-year-old music
legend was cited by the Swedish Academy for "having created new poetic
expressions within the great American song tradition." He will receive a
prize of $927,740.
Born Robert Allen
Zimmerman on May 24, 1941, Dylan became a prolific songwriter and penned some
of the most influential anti-war and civil rights anthems of the 1960s'
counterculture. They include "Blowin' in the Wind," "The Times
They Are a-Changin" and "Subterranean Homesick Blues."
He has also had an
enormous impact on other artists of his generation and beyond, writing songs
that would later be covered by music legends ranging from Jimi Hendrix to
Adele.
I’m
not denying that Bob Dylan has had a large cultural impact, but is song writing
literature? When music and lyrics come
together to form a vocal piece, it’s the music that defines the work, not the
lyrics. The lyrics are a secondary
matter. Take opera for example. The author of an opera is the composer, not
the librettist. We know Le nozze di Figaro as a Mozart
opera. Opera buffs would know that the
librettist was Lorenzo Da Ponte, but even here that’s a special case. Da Ponte served as Mozart’s librettist for a
few of Mozart’s great operas, so he became famous in the opera world. But Mozart had other great operas without Da
Ponte and no one knows who the librettist were for those. How much did Da Ponte contribute in making those
operas with Mozart great? Well, no one
knows any of the operas Da Ponte wrote for other composers. No one knows the librettists for Giuseppe
Verdi’s great operas. Or Rossini’s. Or Pucini’s.
Or just about any other opera.
The
article goes on to say that Dylan’s songs are poetry:
Sara Danius, permanent
secretary of the Nobel Academy, told a news conference Thursday there was
"great unity" in the panel's decision.
"Bob Dylan writes
poetry for the ear," she added. "But it's perfectly fine to read his
works as poetry."
Now
I’m not saying that lyrics are not important to a song. It’s the lyrics that usually construct the
melody. Take for instance Dylan’s song,
“Rainy Day Women.” Here’s the first
verse and chorus from MetroLyrics:
:
Well, they'll stone you
when you're trying to be so good:
They'll stone you just
like they said they would
They'll stone you when
you're tryna go home
Then they'll stone you
when you're there all alone
But I would not feel so
all alone
Everybody must get stoned
The
verse part of the melody “They’ll sto-o-ne you when you’re try-y-ing to be so
goo-ood” is created by (1) the rough meter of the line, (2) the vowel length of
the words, and (3) a stretching of three words in the line, “stone,” a word
just before the final foot of the line (trying, said, tryna, there), and final
word of the line. Then the chorus part
of the melody still keeps that three stretched words, but the line is shorter
and now he shifts the first stretched word from the second word slot to the
first: “But” and “Ev.” Here’s the song
if you want to hear it.
The
point is the lyrics are important to the song but not in the way they are in
poetry. The words are selected not
according to verbal innovation but by commonplace. To be stoned for not following the rules is
actually cliché. The whole song is a cliché,
so that the interest in the song is in the articulation, not the language. Notice also that Dylan occasionally starts a
verse with “Well” or the chorus with “Tell you what” and “yes.” Those are what I call verbal ticks that
communicate attitude. They would be
meaningless in poetry. Notice too the
chuckles and tones in his voice as he articulates the song. Those are elements of songwriting and oral
communication, not literary poetry. The formulaic
repetition of each line simulates a chant.
Poetry would be boring with repetition like that, but because of the
articulation and melody, it holds musical interest. And I would put to you that the majority of
Bob Dylan’s songs contain more interest as a ditty and not as poetry.
Now
that doesn’t mean that there aren’t Dylan compositions where the lyrics could
stand alone as poetry. There are
some. Here’s one, “All Along the WatchTower.”
There must be some way
out of here
Said the joker to the
thief
There's too much
confusion, I can't get no relief
Businessmen, they drink
my wine
Plowmen dig my earth
None of them along the
line know what any of it is worth
No reason to get excited,
the thief, he kindly spoke
There are many here among
us who feel that life is but a joke
But you and I, we’ve been
through that, and this is not our fate
So let us not talk
falsely now, the hour is getting late
All along the watchtower,
princes kept the view
While all the women came
and went, barefoot servants, too
Outside in the distance a
wildcat did growl
Two riders were
approaching, the wind began to howl
It
still highly “songish,” mostly because the line forms a standard verse form,
but there’s a lot of interesting lines and imagery here to make it poetry. Here is a fascinating exegesis of the song:
Yes,
it still comes down to the song elements that enrich the song, but here I feel
confident to say that the poetic elements are of a high caliber here.
Those
two songs represent the extremes, a highly songish composition and a highly
poetic composition. How many songs are
closer to the poetic side? I find very
few. He has a body of work of great
songs, but they are songs, not poems.
Yes, he’s got some lines in songs that are poetic, but a line or two
does not make a poem. For him to receive
the Nobel Prize in Literature is a poor understanding of the distinction
between song and poetry. The Swedish
Academy really botched it.
So
what exactly separates music lyrics from poetry? I see at least three things. First, music lyrics rely heavily on formulaic,
repetitive structures. Poetry has
structure too, but nowhere near the level of structure of music. I don’t believe it’s a coincidence that as
music has become recordable and mass produced that poetry in opposition has
become looser and less form dependent. Second,
music lyrics rely on common phrasing, if not clichéd phrases. Music requires the listener to identify with
the lyrics in order for the artistic experience to resonate. Commonplace language does that. Clichés are antithetical to poetry. Third, music relies on oral articulation and,
most important of all, the musical experience to carry meaning, There are jazz,
rock, and classical songs with just a handful of enigmatic words but where the music
makes the piece whole, gives it unity, completes the meaning. Those words alone are fragmented nothings,
but the music gives it coherence. Music
lyrics rely on the music to give it coherence, where poetry can’t rely on anything
but the words on the page. The more a
song relies on these three elements, the more “songish” I call it, and the less
poetic it is. For the most part, I find
Dylan’s work to be more songish than poetic.
That
is not to say that I dislike Dylan’s songs.
I love his songs. He’s got a
below average singing voice, he’s a mediocre guitar player, and a poor
harmonica player, but his songs are great!
How come? Because he’s a great
composer. Though not particularly
virtuosic, he’s a great song writer.
Might
as well give you another, one I really loved as a teen.
Take me on a trip upon
your magic swirlin' ship
My senses have been
stripped, my hands can't feel to grip
My toes too numb to step,
wait only for my boot heels
To be wanderin'
I'm ready to go anywhere,
I'm ready for to fade
Into my own parade, cast
your dancing spell my way
I promise to go under it.
Hey ! Mr Tambourine Man,
play a song for me
I'm not sleepy and there
is no place I'm going to
Hey ! Mr Tambourine Man,
play a song for me
In the jingle jangle
morning I'll come followin' you.
Source: <a
href="http://www.elyrics.net/read/b/bob-dylan-lyrics/mr.-tambourine-man-lyrics.html">click
here</a>
What
do others think? Literature or
song? Should he have received the Nobel
Prize? What are your favorite Bob Dylan
songs?
I agree with you. If they had decided to break tradition and make a new category for music - I'd have gone 'Congrats Bob'. He just doesn't write Literature.
ReplyDeleteThanks for commenting Zoe. And thanks to Jan too.
DeleteWhat Zoe said.
ReplyDeleteActually Manny, they offered the prize to me first, but I turned it down.
ReplyDeleteBy the way, I have a problem on my blog which needs solving; can you help?
God bless you and yours.
I'll stop by and see. But I'm not very computer savvy.
DeleteI heard a good joke today in reference to a musician winning the Nobel Prize in Literature which I have to share. The Swedish Academy announced early that next year's winner of the Nobel Prize in Literature will be Lin Meng Ning. Who is Lin Meng Ning? He's the guy who writes the fortunes in the Chinese fortune cookies. His classic, "Someday Everything Will Make Perfect Sense" was just too hard to pass by. :)
ReplyDeleteVery funny Manny! Well that joke reminds me of having asked sinner vic why Bob Dylan still has not replied to this No Bell Prize? Long story short, sinner vic told me that he's still debating on Matthew Whether, "I" mean weather or not he will keep the medal that his old back seat rider friend gave him...LOL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TcaL6m6sO2Y
ReplyDeleteGod Bless you and yours
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TcaL6m6sO2Y
ReplyDeleteGo Figure these hackers...lol
Victor, you're too much.
DeleteVictor, you're too much.
DeleteManny, I must give you a complement... Long story short, there's times when on occasions "I" honestly believe that there was no way that you could and/or would understand some of what I was trying to say... nevertheless, you've always been kind and if you couldn't find something nice to say... you simply didn't say anything at the time and I thank you for that.
DeleteGod Bless you and yours my Christian friend.
Good work Manny. I enjoyed it.
ReplyDeleteThank you. :)
DeleteHe is such and influential person. I'm doing a school report about him :)
ReplyDeleteGreat Chris. I hope my blog post helped you.
Delete